Sheared Screw: Tools and Techniques for Effective Removal
A comprehensive guide to safely removing broken screws in various materials and situations
A sheared screw – one that has broken off, often with its head snapped clean off inside a surface – is more than just an annoyance. It can bring plumbing, mechanical, or home repair projects to a grinding halt. Whether you’re dealing with a broken screw stuck in a pipe fitting, an appliance, a furniture piece, or a fixture in wood, metal, or plastic, its removal demands precision, the right tools, and a systematic approach.
At 907 Heating & Plumbing, we’ve encountered countless challenging situations involving stuck and stripped fasteners. In this expert guide, we’ll walk you through safe and effective screw extraction methods, helping you decide when to tackle it as a DIY project and when it’s time to call in a professional plumber or handyman.
Why Do Screws Shear Off? Understanding the Root Cause
Before attempting to remove a snapped screw, understanding why it broke can help prevent future occurrences and inform your removal strategy. Common reasons include:
- Over-tightening: Applying excessive torque can easily snap the screw head or strip the threads, especially with smaller or lower-quality screws. Using a torque wrench can prevent this.
- Corrosion/Rust: Over time, rust and corrosion weaken the metal, making the screw brittle and prone to breaking during removal attempts. This is common in outdoor or wet environments.
- Low-Quality Screws: Cheap materials or poorly manufactured screws often lack the necessary tensile strength and can break easily under stress. Always choose high-quality screws (e.g., stainless steel or coated).
- Stripped Heads: When the screw head becomes stripped (e.g., a Phillips head or flathead camming out), it’s difficult to get proper grip, leading to applied force that can cause the screw to shear.
- Improper Pilot Hole Size: A pilot hole that’s too small creates excessive friction, while one that’s too large reduces thread engagement, both increasing the risk of shearing.
- Angling the Screw Incorrectly: Driving a screw in at an awkward angle can put uneven stress on its shaft, leading to a break.
Essential Tools You’ll Need for Screw Extraction
Preparation is key. Before starting, gather these crucial screw extraction tools:
Step-by-Step Guide: How to Remove a Sheared Screw
Follow these methods from least invasive to most aggressive.
Apply Penetrating Oil (The First Attack)
If the broken screw is rusted or seized, this is your crucial first step. Liberally spray WD-40, PB Blaster, or another quality penetrating oil directly onto the screw and surrounding threads. Allow it to soak for at least 15-30 minutes, or even longer (a few hours or overnight for severely rusted screws). This helps to break down corrosion and lubricate the stuck fastener. You can tap the screw head lightly with a hammer to help the oil penetrate.
Try Pliers or Vice Grips (If Anything is Protruding)
If a small portion of the sheared screw is still sticking out from the surface, this is your easiest option:
- Use locking pliers (Vice Grips) to clamp down firmly on the exposed portion of the screw.
- Twist the pliers slowly and steadily counterclockwise. Apply consistent pressure.
- If the screw is slippery, try wrapping a thick rubber band or a piece of sandpaper around the screw for extra grip before clamping with the pliers.
Drill a Pilot Hole (For Flush or Slightly Recessed Screws)
When the screw is broken off flush with the surface or slightly recessed, you’ll need to drill:
- Center Punch: Use a hammer and a center punch to create a small, precise indentation in the exact center of the broken screw. This prevents the drill bit from wandering.
- Choose Your Drill Bit: Select a small metal drill bit (e.g., 1/8″ or 3mm) that is smaller than the diameter of the screw’s shaft.
- Start Drilling: Using your drill on a slow setting and applying steady pressure, carefully drill into the center-punched mark.
- Use a Left-Handed Drill Bit (Optional but Recommended): If you have left-handed drill bits (designed to spin counterclockwise), use one for the pilot hole. Often, the counterclockwise drilling action itself can loosen the screw and cause it to back out! If not, it still creates the perfect pilot hole for the extractor.
Use a Screw Extractor (The Most Common Solution)
This is typically the most effective method for flush screws:
- Select Extractor Size: Choose a screw extractor from your kit that matches the size of the pilot hole you just drilled. Extractors are typically tapered and have reverse (left-hand) threads.
- Insert Extractor: Gently tap the wider end of the extractor into the drilled hole with a hammer until it’s firmly seated.
- Turn Counterclockwise: Attach an adjustable wrench or a tap wrench to the square end of the extractor. Slowly and firmly turn the wrench counterclockwise. As you turn, the extractor’s reverse threads will bite into the pilot hole, and with enough torque, the broken screw should begin to back out. Be patient and apply steady, increasing pressure.
Cut a New Slot (Dremel Method for Partially Exposed Screws)
If the sheared screw is partially exposed but too flush for pliers, or if the extractor fails:
- Dremel Tool: Fit your rotary tool with a thin cut-off wheel.
- Cut a Slot: Carefully and precisely cut a straight slot across the exposed top of the screw. Make sure the slot is wide and deep enough to accommodate a flathead screwdriver.
- Extract: Insert a flathead screwdriver into the newly cut slot and twist counterclockwise to remove the screw.
Last Resort: Drill It Out (The Destructive Method)
If all else fails and the screw simply won’t budge, you may need to drill it out completely. Understand that this method will destroy the existing threads in the material:
- Increase Drill Bit Size: Gradually increase the size of your metal drill bit, step-by-step, until you drill through the entire screw shaft. Be very careful not to damage the surrounding material or enlarge the hole excessively.
- Clear Debris: Use a shop vacuum to remove all metal shavings.
- Post-Removal: Once the screw is drilled out, you will likely have a damaged or oversized hole. You’ll need to either:
- Re-tap the hole: Use a tap and die set to cut new threads of a larger size.
- Use a thread repair kit: Install a helicoil insert or another type of thread repair solution to create new, strong threads for a replacement screw. This is often the best approach for metal.
- Use a larger screw: In some cases, a larger screw may bite into the enlarged hole, but this is less reliable.
When to Call a Professional Plumber or Handyman
While DIY methods can be highly effective, some situations warrant professional expertise. Don’t risk further damage or injury if:
- The screw is in a critical plumbing fixture: Attempting removal improperly could lead to costly leaks, burst pipes, or significant water damage. Cast iron or PVC plumbing fixtures are particularly sensitive.
- You lack the right tools or experience: Improper drilling can damage surfaces, ruin threads, or embed the screw even deeper. Professional plumbers or handymen have specialized bolt extractors and experience.
- The screw is deeply embedded in sensitive material: Deeply stuck fasteners in expensive appliances, delicate furniture, or structural components require a skilled touch to avoid irreparable harm.
- You’ve tried the methods above and failed: Continuing to force it can make the situation worse.
- The screw is very large or part of an automotive component: Larger broken bolts often require specialized heat treatment or more robust stud extractors.
Professional Assistance Recommended
At 907 Heating & Plumbing, we handle even the most stubborn fasteners safely and efficiently. Contact us today if you need professional extraction services!
Preventing Sheared Screws in the Future
A little foresight can save you a lot of frustration:
- Use Anti-Seize Lubricant: For screws going into metal or in corrosive environments, apply a small amount of anti-seize compound to the threads before installation.
- Avoid Over-tightening: Use a torque wrench where precise fastening is required, or simply hand-tighten until snug, then add a quarter turn.
- Choose High-Quality Screws: Invest in screws made from durable materials like stainless steel, brass, or coated steel, especially for outdoor or high-stress applications.
- Use the Correct Driver Bit: Always match the screwdriver bit type (Phillips, Torx, Robertson, flathead) and size exactly to the screw head to prevent stripping and cam-out.
- Drill Correct Pilot Holes: Ensure your pilot hole size is appropriate for the screw’s diameter and the material.
Final Thoughts
Removing a sheared screw takes patience, the correct tools, and a methodical approach. It’s a common home improvement challenge, but with this DIY guide, you’re well-equipped to tackle many scenarios. However, if you’re unsure, if the screw is in a critical system, or if you fear damaging your property, don’t risk it. Call 907 Heating & Plumbing for reliable, expert service.
Need help with a stuck screw or any plumbing issue?
Our team of experts is ready to assist you with any fastener removal or plumbing needs.
☎️ Call us today for professional assistance!